Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location8.0
Amenities7.7
Service7.5
Cleanliness7.7
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(64)
Positive reviews(21)
Reviews with photos/video(7)
Awesome stay(7)
Friendly staff(7)
Average cleanliness(5)
Delicious breakfast(4)
Negative reviews(5)
Wonderful_time
Amaya Serenity Villa Caldera View with Private Pool & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Feb 2025
Family
3 review
3.5/10
Posted on Apr 3, 2025
Beware of Scammer!
The photos posted by the property should be years ago. Reality you will not get what it looks like.
We booked Serenity room, this is our first trip to Santorini and we tot we can spend more to get a nice view, nice hotel with a big swimming pool.
When we arrived at 9am, as too early so the owner told us this place is not ready yet. We drop off our baggage and went out and came back in the afternoon.
But it still messy, dirty, smelly. Rubbish everywhere.
Swimming pool did not clean up. When u walk in too the room, it’s super smelly and dusty.
Water is cold. No hot water.
The room have only 2 rooms. The owner cheated saying there will be 3 rooms.
Sauna room not functioning and dirty. U won’t feel like going in.
We did complaint and they replace a smaller room for us. Which is the Harmony room type.
And we requested a compensate we change from Serenity room to Harmony. But the owner is super rude and not responsive.
She did not answer any calls. Even trip.com trying to contact her. She refuse to negotiate or answer any calls.
At the end we did not want to cruise our trip but accept the Harmony room while we pay so much higher.
But things didn’t end.
Next day morning there’s stranger outside of our villa. They are doing painting. They did not inform us and we accidentally walk out and make our shoes full of paints.
The worker did not showing us in a polite way but asking us to get in to the room and telling us to wait for 30 mins until the paints dry up.
We complaint to the owner. And here go her showing temper which she can actually just apologize to us politely.
Do not book this property.there’s many nice hotel in Santorini. And we book it for almost 9k for 3 nights.
It’s overly pricey.
Guest User
Amaya Bliss Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Sep 2024
Family
3 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Oct 17, 2024
The cave house is pretty with a nice view, and the staff very friendly
Guest User
Amaya Glamour Villa with Caldera View & Indoor Hot tub
Stayed in Aug 2024
Family
13 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 21, 2024
Fabulous views and lovely staff. Breakfast was great!
Eve
Amaya Windmill Maisonette with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in May 2023
Couple
11 review
4.5/10
Posted on Jun 11, 2023
Stunning views outside the room!
But the room inside…old, moist and moldy, bad smells..
€650/night is absolutely not worth!
LaiAriel
Amaya Glamour Villa with Caldera View & Indoor Hot tub
Stayed in Feb 2024
Solo traveler
1 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Mar 30, 2024
Very good service, and comfortable room.
Guest User
Amaya Castro Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Jan 2023
Family
15 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 26, 2023
The room was lovely - large and clean with a very comfortable bed. Overall very happy with hotel, price, location & facilities.
Chaxingzhe5
Amaya Glamour Villa with Caldera View & Indoor Hot tub
Stayed in Feb 2025
Family
67 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Apr 2, 2025
The environment is very beautiful, the room facilities are also very good, and we were upgraded to a large room. Whether it is the manager or the two waiters, the service is very good. There is also a 24-hour warm water bath on the balcony, with lights, which is very beautiful, although we did not take a bath due to strong winds. The only comment is that there are too few fruits and vegetables in the breakfast, which can be improved.
Original TextTranslated by Google
PALACE21035
Caldera View Amaya Sensational Villa with Hot Tub
Stayed in Dec 2024
Couple
22 review
7.7/10
Good
Posted on Jan 29, 2025
The price is good, the location is OK, I am very satisfied with the room, the breakfast is OK, but the hot spring bath is broken and there is no hot water, so we delayed the check-out... But I booked it just for the hot spring bath, it did not meet my expectations
Original TextTranslated by Google
Am1
Caldera View Amaya Sensational Villa with Hot Tub
Stayed in Mar 2025
Traveling with friends
8 review
8.2/10
Very Good
Posted on Apr 24, 2025
The environment, scenery and service are very good. The hygiene is average. There are hairs on the bed. The breakfast is delicious, but the milk seems sour.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Amaya Harmony Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Nov 2024
Traveling with friends
5 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Dec 18, 2024
The hotel environment is very good, there is a sea view when you go out, the service staff is very patient every day, and the breakfast is also rich.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Amaya Windmill Maisonette with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Nov 2024
Solo traveler
9 review
6.5/10
Posted on Dec 8, 2024
The address on trip.com was different from the actual address, so it was difficult to get around. I couldn't even find the reception.
Original TextTranslated by Google
RapidFly
Amaya Harmony Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Feb 2024
Family
8 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Mar 23, 2024
The hotel is beautiful, especially the scenery, and the house is in Mediterranean style. The hotel's service is also very good. When I contact customer service on WhatsApp, they respond promptly. Another very important point is that many hotels on Holy Island have different room types in different locations, so you have to contact the hotel after getting off the airport, otherwise it will be difficult to find the location. As for their breakfast, they will send someone to deliver it around nine o'clock every day. Remember to put it in the refrigerator if it is not finished, otherwise there will be a lot of ants (personal experience). Overall, it is pretty good.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Amaya Glamour Villa with Caldera View & Indoor Hot tub
Stayed in Jan 2025
Booked for others
55 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 25, 2025
Very good hotel, friends said it was very good
Original TextTranslated by Google
Xiaoxiaoxiaoxiaomao
Amaya Sentiment Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Jun 2024
Family
24 review
1.0/10
Posted on Jul 25, 2024
The address of this hotel is not the same as the address on Ctrip searched on Googlemap. It is not a hotel but a B&B. There is no swimming pool as shown in the photo! Be careful not to be fooled!
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Amaya Bliss Villa with Caldera View & Outdoor Hot Tub
Stayed in Mar 2024
Traveling with friends
39 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on May 2, 2024
In the most beautiful town of Oia. The room behind is another hotel. It looks like 10,000. It is so good that it shares the view with the hotel of 10,000. The swimming pool is heated. The room facilities still show that it is a B&B. It can be improved.