Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location8.1
Amenities7.5
Service8.3
Cleanliness8.1
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(59)
Positive reviews(51)
Reviews with photos/video(11)
Great service(12)
Great location(12)
Awesome stay(9)
Great value for money(7)
Convenient location(6)
Easy to get around(5)
Negative reviews(8)
Guest User
Standard King Room
Stayed in Jun 2025
Family
1 review
4.5/10
Posted on Jul 7, 2025
Unfortunately, our experience did not meet the expectations we had based on the photos and information provided at the time of booking. Upon arrival, we were surprised to find that the hotel was under construction, which was not communicated in advance.
The room we received was significantly smaller than expected and had a fly infestation. Given that we arrived around midnight after a long journey, we were exhausted but still raised our concerns with the manager tWe regret to say that our experience did not meet the expectations we had based on the photos and information provided at the time of booking. Upon our arrival, we were surprised to find that the hotel was under construction, which had not been communicated to us in advance.
The room we were assigned was significantly smaller than we had anticipated and also had a fly infestation. After a long journey, we arrived around midnight, feeling exhausted, but we still raised our concerns with the manager the following morning. Unfortunately, we were informed that the hotel was fully booked and that no alternative room was available.
Additionally, the breakfast area was overcrowded, and despite waiting for a long time, we were unable to get any food. These circumstances forced us to relocate to another hotel in search of a more comfortable stay.
We wanted to share this feedback so that you are aware of the challenges we faced. We hope that steps can be taken to better align the guest experience with the expectations set during the booking process.
Thank you for your time and understanding.
Anthony Maugeri
Standard King Room Extra Floor Space
Stayed in Dec 2024
Business traveler
11 review
7.5/10
Posted on Feb 26, 2025
As depicted. Far on the west side, but easy to walk to subway stations and order car services
Guest User
Standard King Room Extra Floor Space
Stayed in Jan 2024
Traveling with friends
1 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 15, 2024
I would recommend Holiday Inn Manhattan NYC to travelers looking for a comfortable and convenient accommodation option in the heart of Manhattan. With its friendly staff, clean rooms, and prime location, it offers excellent value for a memorable stay in the Big Apple.
Sajib Kundu
Standard Two Double Room
Stayed in Dec 2023
Traveling with friends
5 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 7, 2024
Friendly hotel. Lovely breakfast
Guest User
Standard Two Double Room
Stayed in Aug 2024
Family
5 review
8.5/10
Very Good
Posted on Oct 15, 2024
Great stay, excellent location and fantastic staff.
Muna
Run Of House
Stayed in Apr 2024
Couple
1 review
5.5/10
Posted on May 30, 2024
The hot breakfast was late after 7 am and was not ready on time at 6:30 Am
globe_trotter
Hear Accessible Queen Room Roll In Shower
Stayed in Jan 2024
Solo traveler
4 review
7.5/10
Posted on Feb 18, 2024
Smooth check in and check out service. Appreciated that the hotel help keep luggages after checkout.
Just a little distance from the nearest metro station.
Doggie Traveller
Standard Two Double Room Extra Floor Space
Stayed in May 2023
Family
15 review
8.5/10
Very Good
Posted on Jun 26, 2023
We had to book this last minute and it was in a great location with friendly staff.
Guest User
Standard Two Double Room Extra Floor Space
Stayed in Jul 2023
Family
4 review
2.0/10
Posted on Aug 13, 2023
This hotel was so expensive but it was pretty BAD.
I’ll recommend to lower the price.
It was not clean and it smelled bad too.
Guest User
Standard King Room
Stayed in Apr 2023
Traveling with friends
1 review
7.0/10
Posted on May 26, 2023
Great location. Hotel could use some updating. Very friendly & helpful front desk. Breakfast was good, but very busy.
Unubold Nyamaa
Standard Two Double Room
Stayed in Dec 2024
Traveling with friends
2 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 9, 2025
thank u
Guest User
Superior Two Double Room
Stayed in Nov 2022
Other
17 review
2.0/10
Posted on Dec 25, 2022
I ordered two reservation online of double bed room (Dec 24th and Dec 25th), and we made full payment in advance. at same time,it
obvious labels the order cannot be canceled. however the clerk (the guy working in the night of Dec
24th) sold out my room.
1 He sold out my room without any information , he told me because it is the Christmas Eve and there are many customers. you are late.
2 I have made full payment in advance, the room should belong to me at this time. the employee has been seriously in breach of the contract. it is nothing with late or not.
3 the front dest guy attitude was rude. the guy said you are late you did not inform me, tonight it is so many customers. I said the airline is late. it is out of my control. We were more than 13 hours on the flight. How can I inform you. the guy let me discuss with airline for compensation. it is nothing with him.
4 He hold my credit cark in whole night without inform me. I do not know what he done in my credit card.
This holiday inn is trash, it out of your mind.
석예인
Standard Two Double Room
Stayed in Apr 2024
Traveling with friends
4 review
6.0/10
Posted on May 21, 2024
Not good
Guest User
Standard King Room Extra Floor Space
Stayed in Mar 2025
Business traveler
33 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Apr 24, 2025
The hotel is located in the center of Manhattan, with convenient transportation, good location, convenient shopping, warm and thoughtful service from the staff, and a comfortable environment. The hotel has a good breakfast, good location, convenient transportation, and cleanliness.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Chengzixingzou
Standard King Room
Stayed in Nov 2024
Couple
33 review
8.2/10
Very Good
Posted on Dec 11, 2024
The room that costs 300 yuan in China is only 2700 yuan in Manhattan, New York. Don't think it's expensive. It's fully booked. The exterior wall is being renovated. You can't even see the sign. The lobby is very small. The receptionists are expressionless and calm, unlike the enthusiastic ones in China. The breakfast room is also on the first floor. It's very cramped when there are many people. The food is just ordinary American food, mainly high in sugar, oil and calories. The room is very small, the bathroom is small, the washbasin is small, everything is small, it's difficult for two people to open the suitcase, but the hygiene is good. Because it is located in Midtown, it is convenient to walk from the city to the upper city, and it takes 10 minutes to walk to the Intrepid Aircraft Carrier Museum. It takes 46 dollars to take a taxi to the Stanten Island Ferry Terminal in the lower city to see the Statue of Liberty. There are no restaurants around. It takes 15 minutes to walk to some small shops. It's just like that in the United States. One more thing to add: It costs nearly 100 dollars to take a taxi from JFKT8 to the hotel, and Ctrip pick-up is less than 500, and there is a free one-hour waiting time (including the landing of the plane). If everything goes well, it's almost enough time to go through customs.