Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point
Select date
-
Select date
1 night
All properties in Jerusalem

Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point

Jerusalem, New York State, 14527
Show on map
Complete address will show after booking
We Price Match
hotel overview picture
Amenities
Wi-Fi in public areas
BBQ
No smoking in public areas
Garden
Kayaking
Clothes dryer
Handrails on stairs
All amenities
Property Description
Lakeside paradise awaits you at this exceptional three-story home. Situated just steps from the water on the exclusive East Bluff of Keuka Lake, Prop Point promises an unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation! The first-floor entry welcomes you with an open floorplan and large lake facing picture windows. The cool blue waves of Keuka Lake will have you mesmerized within a moments time. The perfect blend of warm and cool neutral, decorative tones are scattered about the open floor plan. Tall cabinets accentuate the height of the kitchen walls while the deep granite counter tops offer ample space for prepping meals. A beautiful wooden dining table overlooks the lake and makes you feel as though you’re dining alfresco. The formal living area continues these same lake views and adds the warmth of a gas fireplace for those chilly evenings. Throughout the house, four bedrooms designed with relaxation and comfort have been styled for your vacation pleasure. Choose the bedroom perfect for you and rest up while staying at your new “home away from home.” The finished, lower level contains a cozy family room with large TV. Glass doors give you direct access to the lower-level patio overlooking the lake. This space is perfect for outdoor dining and lounging. The lakefront features a surpassingly beautiful landscaped area and gradual entry into the lake. Enjoy watching your children play from one of the perfectly placed Adirondack chairs. Sunbathe, fish off the dock, swimming in the crystal clean water, or making the biggest splash jumping into Keuka Lake, fun is endless…. Prop Point is located only a few miles from the town of Penn Yan, where you will find unique shops on Main Street, plenty of dining, locally famous Seneca Farms, and the Windmill Farmers Market. Award winning wineries like Hunt Country Vineyards and Stever Hill Vineyards and Yates Cellars are within minutes from this Keuka Lake gem. This is the perfect getaway for your next family vacation or couple’s weekend. Note: Smoking is not allowed in the property. Home is not handicap accessible, unless stated in description. Pets are not allowed. Take stairs down to 110 feet private shoreline is yours to enjoy. Sunbathe, fish off the dock, swimming in the crystal clean water, or making the biggest splash jumping into Keuka Lake, fun is endless…. About pets:No pets allowed.About checkOut:Check out before 10:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 21.About events:No events allowed.
Show more
10.0/10
Outstanding
Cleanliness10.0
Amenities10.0
Location10.0
Service10.0
All 48 reviews
Surroundings
Airport: Elmira Corning Regional Airport
(84.7 km)
Landmarks: Garrett Memorial Chapel
(1.1 km)
View on map

Overview

Rooms

Guest Reviews

Services & Amenities

Policies

Host

12

4 Bedrooms Private Vacation Home

4 bedrooms: 1 bunk bed 1 single bed and 4 queen beds
Non-smoking
Room Details
Check Availability

Guest Reviews

10.0/10
Outstanding
48 reviews
Verified Reviews
  • Cleanliness10.0
  • Amenities10.0
  • Location10.0
  • Service10.0
Average for similar properties in Jerusalem
Most Mentioned
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
October 9, 2025
Very comfortable, clean, and as-advertised! A beautiful property and location, highly recommended!
D‍a‍v‍i‍d‍ ‍K‍.
October 3, 2025
We absolutely loved the home! The host provided everything we needed and were extremely easy to communicate with! Our family was looking for somewhere to stay due to a family wedding being held in the area, and we found paradise! We are hoping to possibly returning next year!
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
September 22, 2025
Stunning views, very clean, and descriptions were very accurate. Owners clearly take excellent care of the property.
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
September 11, 2025
Perfect house for our family vacation. Outdoor space has everything you could possibly need. Inside is clean, well stocked and comfortable. Host was a pleasure to communicate with and response was immediate. We are all looking forward to coming back to Prop Point next year. Thank you!
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
September 6, 2025
Loved our entire stay. So pretty. No reason to leave but we did tent a boat for one afternoon. Fishing from the dock was lots of fun. We caught 5 different species. Auntie and a nest were glorious. HopeTo come back sometime soon.
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
August 31, 2025
The house was immaculate and matched the listing. Very spacious and well equipped. We like to cook and used the kitchen extensively and found it very well equipped. We tied up our rental pontoon boat at the dock. Had no issues and a lovely week.
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
August 24, 2025
Perfect location. Beautiful home . Be sure to bring your beach towels!!. Will be back again next year
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
July 21, 2025
Excellent. Couldn't ask for better house, location, amenities, accommodations or more helpful host. Can't wait for the chance to return.
G‍u‍e‍s‍t‍ ‍U‍s‍e‍r
July 17, 2025
Beautiful property! The house was clean and stocked with everything you would need - everything was clearly labeled and organized which made things even easier to find. The dock was awesome and the beach access was perfect for the kids to play around in the water. Plenty of room for parking and easy access to the house to carry all our gear in. Daisy was quick to respond to our questions which was much appreciated. We would definitely stay there again!

Services & Amenities

More Amenities
Internet
Public areas
Health & wellness
Cleaning services
Accessibility

Property Policies

Check-in and Check-out Times
Check-in: after 16:00
Check-out: Before 10:00
Child policies
Children of all ages are welcome at this property.
Additional fees may be charged for children using existing beds. Add the number of children to get a more accurate price.

Cribs and Extra Beds
Please contact the hotel for details about crib and extra bed policies.

Age Requirements
The main guest checking in must be at least 21 years old

Property host

Daisy Keller
Speaks: English

About this property

Lakeside paradise awaits you at this exceptional three-story home. Situated just steps from the water on the exclusive East Bluff of Keuka Lake, Prop Point promises an unforgettable Finger Lakes vacation! The first-floor entry welcomes you with an open floorplan and large lake facing picture windows. The cool blue waves of Keuka Lake will have you mesmerized within a moments time. The perfect blend of warm and cool neutral, decorative tones are scattered about the open floor plan. Tall cabinets accentuate the height of the kitchen walls while the deep granite counter tops offer ample space for prepping meals. A beautiful wooden dining table overlooks the lake and makes you feel as though you’re dining alfresco. The formal living area continues these same lake views and adds the warmth of a gas fireplace for those chilly evenings. Throughout the house, four bedrooms designed with relaxation and comfort have been styled for your vacation pleasure. Choose the bedroom perfect for you and rest up while staying at your new “home away from home.” The finished, lower level contains a cozy family room with large TV. Glass doors give you direct access to the lower-level patio overlooking the lake. This space is perfect for outdoor dining and lounging. The lakefront features a surpassingly beautiful landscaped area and gradual entry into the lake. Enjoy watching your children play from one of the perfectly placed Adirondack chairs. Sunbathe, fish off the dock, swimming in the crystal clean water, or making the biggest splash jumping into Keuka Lake, fun is endless…. Prop Point is located only a few miles from the town of Penn Yan, where you will find unique shops on Main Street, plenty of dining, locally famous Seneca Farms, and the Windmill Farmers Market. Award winning wineries like Hunt Country Vineyards and Stever Hill Vineyards and Yates Cellars are within minutes from this Keuka Lake gem. This is the perfect getaway for your next family vacation or couple’s weekend. Note: Smoking is not allowed in the property. Home is not handicap accessible, unless stated in description. Pets are not allowed. Take stairs down to 110 feet private shoreline is yours to enjoy. Sunbathe, fish off the dock, swimming in the crystal clean water, or making the biggest splash jumping into Keuka Lake, fun is endless…. About pets:No pets allowed.About checkOut:Check out before 10:00 AM.About children:Children allowed: ages 0-17.About checkIn:Check in after 4:00 PM.About smoking:Smoking is not permitted.About minBookingAge:Minimum age to rent: 21.About events:No events allowed.
Show Full Description

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the cancellation policy at Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point?

The cancellation policy at Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point depends on your room type and booking terms.

What are the check-in and check-out times at Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point?

Check-in at Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point starts from 16:00, and the standard check-out time is by 10:00.

How do I get to Keuka Lake Paradise - Prop Point from the nearest airport?

The nearest airport is Elmira Corning Regional Airport, located about about 1 hour 14 mins from hotel by car (84.7 km) away.

About This Property

Nearest AirportElmira Corning Regional Airport
Distance to Airport84.69KM
Hotel Star Rating3