Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location8.9
Amenities8.8
Service8.9
Cleanliness9.0
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(115)
Positive reviews(15)
Reviews with photos/video(3)
Guest User
Superior Double Room with Golf View
Stayed in Jun 2025
Couple
1 review
7.5/10
Posted on Jul 22, 2025
Having visited this hotel many times over the years, we were looking forward to return. We opted to pay for the upgrade to our room to a suite. The furnishings are tired, the dressing table worn and the curtains do not actually shut out all the light as they do not go far enough along beside the wardrobe.
The food was average, service was slow and mistakes were made to the point our desserts were given for free on our last evening.
When checking out I also feel we were carefully asked if everything was ok upstairs meaning our room - not asked about our stay etc.
It's really disappointing as it has been a favourite place for our family to visit but I doubt we would return.
The brie starter said it had oatmeal coating - it was not oatmeal. The venison was overcooked and very sweet. The chicken caesar salad i couldn't eat the meat - it was so peppery and spiced with cajun - not described on the menu.
Guest User
Standard Double Room
Stayed in Jun 2025
Couple
1 review
7.5/10
Posted on Jul 4, 2025
The staff were all excellent however the hotel itself is badly in need of an upgrade. The furniture in the bedrooms is old and dated as are the carpets in the guest hallways and bedrooms. The was no fridge in the bedroom either.
Guest User
Standard Double Room
Stayed in Apr 2025
Traveling with friends
1 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on May 16, 2025
Recent golfing trip to Carnoustie and stayed at Carnoustie Golf Hotel. Great stay and can see some refurbishments throughout the hotel since last visited. Great stay - Faultless
Guest User
Standard Double Room
Stayed in Dec 2024
Couple
1 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jan 18, 2025
Excellent hotel with a wonderful view of a golf course and a beach, well connected by road and local buses into other nearby towns and Dundee.
Excellent breakfast with good dinner available at the restaurant - good ambience. Spacious rooms with lovely coffee machine. Very courteous and cordial staff.
Overall a great experience with a swimming pool and leisure club included within the package. Will highly recommend.
Sebastian Hammill
Standard Double Room
Stayed in May 2024
Couple
2 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Aug 1, 2024
It was a nice place with lots of space, had lots of amenities and was a very comfy place to relax in too with a golf course, pool, jacuzzi and steam room with a sauna.
Debbie
Standard Double Room
Stayed in Oct 2024
Family
1 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Dec 20, 2024
We weren’t made aware that the hotels leisure facilities weren’t available during our stay due to refurbishment but aside from that a beautiful hotel in a wonderful setting.
tonyflynn
Standard Twin Room
Stayed in Dec 2024
Couple
3 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Jan 20, 2025
It was amazing place to stay all in all just brill
Chris7500
Standard Twin Room
Stayed in Oct 2023
Family
1 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Nov 8, 2023
We started the trip in the bar with quick orders of drinks but found it quite strange that there wasn’t a drinks menu but other than that we sat in a comfy lounge area and then checked in quickly our room was really spacious for the price then we went down to enjoy the pool amenities which with a heated pool quite large and a steam room with eucalyptus oil we assume by the end of our night were so relaxed which was our entire expectation for the trip and the hotel exceeded it
Guest User
Junior Suite
Stayed in Jun 2024
Family
14 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Aug 18, 2024
Very comfortable hotel, with a golf course behind it and the beach next to it. It is convenient to walk to the train station and the town. There is also a children's playground by the sea.
Original TextTranslated by Google
poony
Superior Double Room with Golf View
Stayed in Jul 2024
Traveling with friends
18 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 20, 2024
Worth a try. The beach is beautiful.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Chongqingyajie
Standard Twin Room
Stayed in Oct 2023
Couple
13 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jan 17, 2024
Clean and comfortable beds
Environment: Very good, seaside, clear air
Service: Very good, rich breakfast
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Standard Twin Room
Stayed in Dec 2023
Traveling with friends
28 review
8.0/10
Very Good
Posted on Jan 4, 2024
The environment is great and it is very convenient to play golf