Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location8.5
Amenities7.0
Service7.2
Cleanliness6.1
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(130)
Positive reviews(30)
Reviews with photos/video(10)
Convenient location(10)
Awesome stay(9)
Nice sea view(9)
Average cleanliness(6)
Easy to get around(6)
Close to train station(6)
Negative reviews(6)
Shane Jury
Twin Room
Stayed in Mar 2025
Couple
1 review
5.0/10
Posted on May 13, 2025
Great location, hotel is in shocking condition! Room was incredibly tired and not clean. But it was cheap!
Hannah9
Double Room with Sea View
Stayed in Mar 2025
Couple
1 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Apr 27, 2025
High recommend Very welcoming environment lovly staff food and stay was amazing no complaints from our end the veiw was amazing from our balcony sea veiw room was breath taking couldn’t of ask for a better night stay definitely going to book again
Guest User
Double Room
Stayed in Mar 2025
Couple
1 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Apr 28, 2025
Rooms are a bit run down and carpets definitely need redoing ,but lovely service,very welcoming and hospitable.price can be good depending on what days and season but overall a lovely little place to stay. It’s a 10 minute walk to the beach and 4 minutes from the train station
Guest User
Single Room
Stayed in Apr 2025
Traveling with friends
1 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on May 13, 2025
The view of the room is so fantastic, I really had a good time there
Alan
Superior Double Room
Stayed in Jun 2025
Couple
12 review
7.0/10
Posted on Jul 8, 2025
Location is amazing. Town is a quick few minutes, train station is about 5 minutes, as well as the beach. Hotel itself is worn and needs a revamp. Stay for the location and not much more.
Mallu Couple Travellers
Twin Room
Stayed in Oct 2024
Couple
14 review
8.0/10
Very Good
Posted on Nov 11, 2024
During our three-day stay at The St Ives Bay Hotel, we had a memorable and relaxing experience as a couple. Our beach-view room was an absolute delight, offering stunning vistas of the ocean right from our window. The gentle sounds of the waves crashing on the shore were incredibly soothing, making every morning and evening special.
The room itself was spacious, providing more than enough room to unwind and truly feel at ease. We appreciated the hotel’s accessibility, with both bus and train services conveniently close by, making it easy for us to explore the charming town of St Ives and its beautiful surroundings. This convenience added an extra layer of ease to our holiday.
On top of everything, the hotel’s rates were budget-friendly, offering excellent value for such a great location and amenities. For couples seeking a comfortable and scenic getaway, The St Ives Bay Hotel is a wonderful option that doesn’t break the bank. We’d love to return!
6/20
Krit
Superior Double Room
Stayed in May 2025
Solo traveler
6 review
6.0/10
Posted on Jul 10, 2025
The location is perfect, you just take 5 5-minute walk to the train station. However, the room appears to be quite old compared to the picture provided on the website. Especially in the bathroom, which makes me feel like it is not well prepared before the guests arrive.
Claire Mint
Double Room
Stayed in Apr 2025
Couple
4 review
8.0/10
Very Good
Posted on May 19, 2025
Very great location. Porthminster beach and train station are just in front of the hotel.
Guest User
Double Room
Stayed in Feb 2025
Couple
1 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Mar 24, 2025
Great location. Basic hotel but can’t complain for the price we paid. The view was amazing over Porthminster Beach and the station,
Eva Hussain
Twin Room
Stayed in Feb 2025
Couple
2 review
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Mar 7, 2025
The check-in was easy and quick. Paul was very welcoming and helpful. Good experience. The cupboard in the room was not cleaned and could see sticky cup marks.
Anonymous User
Double Room with Sea View
Stayed in Jul 2024
Family
1 review
6.0/10
Posted on Sep 2, 2024
The location was superb, with easy access to Porthminster Beach and the train station right across from the hotel. There is also a paid parking space available. It’s a 15-minute walk to shops and restaurants, which is convenient.
As for the hotel itself, you get what you pay for. The service could use some improvement. Our room wasn’t cleaned daily, and when we arrived, the electric fan, table, and small purple cushion were dusty and dirty. Additionally, our left luggage was stored in the emergency exit area for safekeeping. The staff was okay, but there's room for improvement.
G0J0
Twin Room
Stayed in Jul 2024
Traveling with friends
4 review
4.0/10
Posted on Aug 17, 2024
Disappointed with the service provided by the receptionist. There are quite a few staircases where luggage is not a good choice to stay there. Where you will need to carry your luggage up and down.
Requested carpark lot but no reply from the hotel.
Saw the carpark behind the building that was dedicated to the hotel, but the reception did not mention it.
Conclusion;
Cleanliness - good
Location - good
Reception - very bad
Georgina Ellen
Double Room
Stayed in Oct 2024
Couple
1 review
7.5/10
Posted on Nov 4, 2024
The most amazing view from this room. Really great location, within easy walking distance to the centre of St Ives. You get what you pay for with this hotel, although the view is definitely a bonus.
Guest User
Single Room
Stayed in Jun 2024
Solo traveler
13 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Aug 1, 2024
Friendly staff, good sized communal areas and nice view. Single bedroom carpet however quite stained and walls and windows thin so fairly noisy
Guest User
Single Room
Stayed in Jun 2024
Other
1 review
7.0/10
Posted on Jul 14, 2024
Nice experience I enjoyed by the beach and the view of the beach on the hotel Amazing