Island City House

We stayed at the island city house, celebrating our anniversary, June 5th- June 8th . We have been going to Key West every year, since we got married there 11 years ago. We try to find new properties to explore. But, this is our favorite by far. Check in was a breeze, Annette was an angel! She helped make our visit wonderful! The room was spacious , clean and well appointed. Everything we needed was easily accessible. The hotel is close to everything, you can easily walk to many delicious eateries, and shop your heart away. Parking can be tricky, so we opted for the lot parking on Southern . The grounds are simply stunning , one of the best in my opinion in Key West. The property is quiet, the pool was a welcoming relief after biking around the island . Do yourself a favor , make sure you visit the beaches of Fort Zachary Taylor. Snorkeling around there will make your trip even more memorable. The beach is clean, and the water is gorgeous . At the time of our visit, Smathers beach was mostly seaweed and not inviting . We had a wonderful time celebrating at Island City House! You will not be disappointed.

A homeless man camped out on our balcony one night. He paced back and forth, mumbling and swearing loudly to himself right outside our flimsy french doors. I fully expected him to come crashing in at any moment. When I called the night manager, he said he would come and take care of it. After 90 minutes, I called back. The night manager, who had clearly been asleep, claimed he had come and not seen anything. I asked him to come back, and he swore at me and told me to just deal with it! Unbelievable!

Key West hotel Great place to stay in Key West. Restaurants and shops all walkable.

Enjoyed the room, bathroom, kitchenette. Quite and comfortable. HATRED the cats!!

Stayed here for 5 nights for a birthday celebration. The grounds were gorgeous and the location is perfect. The accommodations are basic and need updating to justify the 500+ per night costs. Everywhere you look it’s apparent the accommodations aren’t well maintained. Received two $5 vouchers for breakfast, which was sad compared to comparable accommodations. We spoke with others and saw similar accommodations that were much nicer and better maintained than this hotel. Left disappointed as we wanted a special stay and it was just not great. Recommend staying elsewhere on the island if you want a special stay.

The room was awesome due to having a separate living area and kitchen area, the bed was soft and comfy, it was really spacious clean and safe. The pool was so nice and the garden area was spectacular I loved it.