The Islander Inn

I like that the hotel is located just few miles to the beach.

Amazing!!

The room was spacious, and the fridge with a freezer compartment was a nice touch. Basic toiletries were provided, which is expected at this price point. However, the room had no window, making it extremely dark—definitely not a place where you’d want to spend time beyond sleeping. On top of that, the ceiling AC was incredibly loud, making it hard to get a good night’s rest. Unlike other rooms, our room didn’t have outdoor seating either. When I mentioned at the front desk that $350 per night for a windowless room seemed unreasonable, the only response I got was: “Sorry, these are the rates around here.” No understanding, no effort to make it right—just a dismissive reply. For this price, I expected much more. If that is the last room, without window, no outdoor seating, they should sell it for less instead of more.

Terrific location - truly walking distance from the beach, and also walking distance from restaurants of various price points. The hotel is old-style Florida - well kept courtyard, small pool area with good number of chairs and mix of shade and sun. Nice places to sit outside your room. And a nice vibe of guests quietly enjoying the space without disturbing others. The manager and staff are lovely - warm, helpful, and visibly present. All the little things worked well - beach chairs for the beach were always available; easy to get more beach towels when we needed them; and a fun happy hour on Friday evening, plus the coffee and muffins each morning. Parking worked exactly as expected - we got a hotel-reserved spot every night except one, and on that night we easily parked just a few spots over without any trouble. Everything was fully as advertised and nicer overall than we expected. The rooms were very clean, airy, and the AC worked very well. Excellent water pressure and temperature. Probably the only things I'd quibble about would be walls a bit thin (note that we were never disturbed by our neighbours, even though we could hear them from time to time), bed very firm (fine for sleeping, but would have helped to have a few more (and plusher) pillows for reading in bed), and though they've made a valiant effort at adding spots for charging, I wished for one that was directly beside the bed, since I use my phone to tell the time if I wake up at night. Again - very, very minor issues. An fun bonus was that our room number happened be our son's player number - apt since we were there to watch him during highschool spring training at the Jackie Robinson complex, an easy 20 minute drive away. Our stay was lovely, and we'd definitely return.

Great location! Very clean, accommodating staff. Nice pool, pool chairs and umbrellas. The rooms could use some updating, but the location was great, right downtown and across from the beach. We were in a bad room that wasn’t described on the website. However, after conversing with Jeff, he was accomodating to move us to a better room

Great service and location. Property is well managed and very clean. Enjoyed the Saturday Happy Hour as well as morning coffee and muffins. Use of free bikes and beach chairs was an added bonus.