The Preston House and Hotel

Thankyou again for another amazing stay. This was our 3rd visit to this wonderful hotel. The rooms are very well appointed. Comfortable beds and incredible staff. We highly recommend this location if staying in the Hamptons or visiting Long Island.

We want to extend our sincere thanks to Alberto and Daniel, who went above and beyond to make our stay unforgettable from the moment we arrived. Their exceptional hospitality and attention to detail made our experience extraordinary! Alberto has a remarkable gift for capturing our kids’ hearts, and he consistently makes them feel special, creating memories that will last a lifetime. Daniel's kindness and accommodating nature only added to our wonderful experience. We look forward to our upcoming stay and can't wait to share the magic of The Preston House with our extended family from abroad. It’s truly a pleasure spending our summer & winter getaways in such a warm and inviting boutique hotel.

One of the most luxurious hotels on Long Island. The front desk staff provide exceptional service and are very attentive to all requests. Definitely feels like an elevated experience compared to other hotels on Long Island.

Excellent staff members, extremely attentive and timely with service. Front desk was patient with my family's request and especially kind to my toddler. Highly recommend this hotel to other guests and looking forward to our next stay here.

Excellent hotel. Very clean & gracious staff. Danielle, Valentina and Susan made my trip. Food was great downstairs too. Walking distance to everything and convenient to airport. Room was spacious and clean. Would highly recommend. Thank you!!

We wanted to express our sincere gratitude for the exceptional hospitality and generosity we experienced during our recent stay at The Preston House and Hotel. Alberto outstanding service and attention to detail truly made our time unforgettable! We have been greeted with warmth from the moment we arrived, and the impeccable cleanliness and maintenance of the hotel facilities further exemplify their commitment to excellence. We are particularly grateful for the extra gestures of kindness and thoughtfulness that were extended to us, such as your list of restaurant recommendations nearby. Alberto’s genuine care for the comfort and satisfaction of ensuring that every guest has a memorable experience, along with his hands-on approach, has been evident in the seamless coordination of every aspect of the hotel's operations. This has been reflected in every interaction we had with the staff, especially the delicious morning iced cappuccino! The personable service we received throughout our stay provided a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere, allowing us to fully unwind and enjoy every moment. Thank you for your dedication to creating a welcoming environment where guests feel truly valued and cared for. We wholeheartedly recommend The Preston House and Hotel to friends, family, and colleagues, and look forward to returning in the very near future!

If you're staying in Riverhead, odds are the location had chosen you rather than you choosing the location. But regardless of the reason you wound up here, you should stay at the Preston House and Hotel. As opposed to the the Hyatt Place across the street, the Preston House and Hotel has a boutique and elevated feel. The staff could not be any nicer and attentive to our needs. The breakfast in the morning is delicious and mostly home-cooked though best to supplement with some truly North Fork cuisine. The rooms are new, modern, and spacious. Pro tip: to enjoy a blackout shade experience use hangers as pictured to prevent light from coming in the morning. We also found the restaurant to be very nice food and convenient. This hotel is appropriately rated as 4 stars. A five star experience for us.

We were attending a Valentines dinner at the Aquarium and didn't want to drive back home. We chose The Preston House over the Hyatt even though Hyatt was giving a discount if you had reservations at the Aquarium. What a GREAT choice. The people are so friendly and professional. The room was exactly how it was shown on the website (when does THAT ever happen). Susan and the manager Alberto are awesome !! We didn't eat at the restaurant but did have cocktails at the bar. Very pleasant atmosphere. We're planning on going back and this time staying more than one night.

Absolutely loved it! We were in the area for a wedding nearby. Wish we could have stayed a couple of days more. Our room was very clean. The bed was comfortable. Wide screen TVs were a huge plus. We loved the complimentary fresh coffee every day. It was so nice to take a shower and not have to wait for the water to get hot. We actually liked that the hotel is smaller. There was absolutely zero noise and we slept so well. Staff very friendly and check in/check out was a breeze. We can't wait to return. This hotel is in our top three and we've stayed at so many hotels. We'll be back for sure!