Plumsteadville Inn

Lacks charm but a nice stay. We stayed in a room on the "Old side" of the Inn. The way to the room was up 2 or 3 stairways and through a hallway and down another hallway to the room. Aside from being part of the original Inn, which was cool, it lacked the charm I would expect from a restored Historical site. Food was great and Sunday Brunch also great. We were told that our brunch would be 1/2 price ($12.50) but in the end only $10 was credited on the whole bill. We also did not have a table as we were not informed to reserve even though we stayed there. Was overall a good time. 3 stars.

It’s tough to review this place because we thought the staff, the restaurant and wait staff & food were really good, but we had a few issues with the accommodations. There should have been a secondary lock on the inside of the room, not just a push button doorknob lock. We know it’s a nice place, but it was somewhat uncomfortable for us, especially in a high traffic hallway. The thermostat was not working properly (even though the manager came up to try and adjust it) we were chilly both nights we stayed there. Thankfully the blankets kept us warm. The shower water pressure was horrible and kept switching from hot & cold mid-showers. Our check-in & check-out were easy and it was nice that the manager brought us to our room. Also was easy booking reservations for dinner & brunch. Both meals we had at the Inn were great.

We will return We ejoyed our stay quant and comfortable. Staff was very friendly and helpful.