Mutiny Hotel on the Bay Coconut Grove Miami

I've stayed at The Mutiny Hotel several times now, in both standard and refurbished rooms, so I’ve experienced the full range of what this property has to offer — the good and the not-so-good. Unfortunately, I’m finding it harder to overlook some recurring issues that the management really needs to address. Based on my experience and that of many other reviewers, it's time for real improvements. First, cleanliness and maintenance are inconsistent at best. While some units are very clean and clearly cared for, others feel neglected. One of the rooms I stayed in needed a serious deep clean. The kitchen area in particular was disappointing — equipped with only the most basic tools and, worse, the pots and pans were filthy. While there are dishwashers in the units, I had to put things through several times, so filters really need looking at. That’s just not acceptable for a property of this standard. The carpets throughout the hotel are another problem: they are long overdue for a professional deep clean. Another issue is the air conditioning. In more than one unit I’ve stayed in, the AC units were incredibly loud — to the point where sleeping through the night could be difficult. It’s a disturbance that really takes away from what should be a relaxing stay and clearly needs to be looked into. Staff-wise, most are friendly, helpful, and professional, which I appreciate and want to acknowledge. However, I did encounter one staff member who was surprisingly rude and dismissive — a stark contrast to the otherwise pleasant team. For a hotel experience to be consistent, that kind of attitude simply can’t be allowed. The pool is a bright spot — clean and enjoyable — though the loungers need proper cushions covers as they were a little dirty. There’s also a restaurant on site. There’s no clear signage, no posted hours, and no menu anywhere to be found. It’s a missed opportunity to add value for guests and boost the property’s appeal. (Also a revenue opportunity) In short, this hotel could be a truly great place to stay. It has potential — the location, the refurbished units all point to that. But without serious attention from ownership and management — especially regarding cleaning, maintenance, and basic guest comfort — it’s falling far short. I sincerely hope they start listening to the feedback, because it’s coming from a lot more than just me.

Overall, for the location and cost, this property is a logical choice for many types of travelers looking to stay in one of the better spots in Miami. While I stayed here for a business trip, I could see myself staying here for a vacation. The mixed reviews are likely from the “uniqueness” of each room since rooms are privately owned. No complaints with my 11th floor room which faced west. Candidly, room decor was basic (almost “no frills”), but for a two night business trip, it was perfect. Very nice having a balcony and a kitchenette. Nice living area with a sofa and table. Good size bathroom. AC worked just fine; plenty of hot water; quiet; relaxing views from the balcony. Decent small gym; nice pool. Housekeeping was good. No issues with valet parking. Staff were friendly and helpful. Nice vibe and decor in lobby; nice first impression upon arriving. Interesting history of the hotel (look it up). Coconut Grove is a wonderful Miami neighborhood with plenty of restaurants, bars, and shops all within a 5 minute walk from The Mutiny. Great evening walks also along Bayshore, Peacock Park, and nearby marinas.

Stay elsewhere. This is a tired, very run down hotel. Carpet was disgusting, furniture worn out, bathroom outdated, tub peeling. You don't know about the cleaning fee until you check out, which is added to a resort fee. This is no resort. Great neighborhood, but find another place!

We liked the property. Convenient location.